Taste the American whisky revolution with the best of the Kentucky Bourbon Trail

Our drinks expert Neil Ridley tackles the Kentucky Bourbon Trail, kicking off in Louisville, to taste-test the best American whiskies – consult his shoppable guide in time for World Whisky Day on 17 May

American Whisky
Left, a barrel at The Bardstown Bourbon Company. Right, the home of Jim Beam
(Image credit: Neil Ridley)

It's safe to say that American whisky is usually the gateway into dark spirits for many of us.

It certainly was for me, over 25 years ago, when I was first offered a hastily poured Jack Daniel's over ice at a house party. What immediately struck me was the extraordinary spectrum of flavours in the glass, compared to Irish whisky and the small number of Scotches I had tried at that point: sweet, then savoury and spice-laden, then sour, then back to something mellow, vanilla-heavy and oaky... it piqued my interest in the wider world of whisky, of which I’m as passionate as ever, all these years later.

Kentucky Bourbon Trail Craft Tour sign

(Image credit: Neil Ridley)

Today, the category of American whisky is certainly going through a transformation – something akin to the way Scotch did a decade ago –with a rise in popularity for limited-edition, small-batch releases, single-barrel offerings and highly prestigious, ultra-premium releases with age statements well into the teens and beyond, all of which command huge respect from spirits collectors and, of course, come with suitably high price tags.

A traditional American house in Bardstown, with a porch

A traditional house in Bardstown, which is home to multiple distilleries and known as the ‘Bourbon capital'

(Image credit: Neil Ridley)

Alongside this development comes a greater focus on the ‘grain-to-glass’ concept: taking a much greater understanding of the growing conditions and ecology of the raw materials used in making bourbon, as well as highlighting the sustainability and regenerative practices that are being widely celebrated by the global distilling community.

A whisky still at Jeptha Creed distillery, Kentucky

A still at Jeptha Creed distillery

(Image credit: Neil Ridley)

For the uninitiated, it's probably prudent to take a brief look at just what's under the skin of some of our favourite American whiskies and a little history behind the spirit.

A shot of American whisky history

The story arguably begins during the 1600s, when European settlers travelled to America, bringing with them distillation know-how: what they found was a country full of agricultural potential and the right conditions to grow the all-important grains used in the production of whisky, such as corn, rye and wheat. By the 1700s, Kentucky’s rich ‘bluegrass lands’ – and also Tennessee – became synonymous with the art of whisky distillation, which attracted more European settlers: such as Welshman, Evan Williams, who was instrumental in establishing Kentucky’s 'Bourbon Country' (more on exactly what makes a bourbon whisky later).

Rabbithole bottles

Rabbit Hole whiskies

(Image credit: Neil Ridley)

The Mississippi River proved pivotal in providing access to the coast for exports to both America's big cities and overseas markets. However, as the 1920s roared in, disaster struck, when the Volstead Act (or Prohibition, as it is more commonly known) came into play and for a period of 13 years, distillation became illegal, leading to the closure of many distilleries (just six remained open in Kentucky, producing whisky for 'medicinal purposes'), leaving only a few major players to keep up with demand once the act was repealed in 1933.

Maker's Mark Star Hill Farm

Maker’s Mark’s base, Star Hill Farm

(Image credit: Neil Ridley)

The 1980s and 1990s were a lean time for the industry, but change was afoot. The world began once again to get a taste for American whisky and thanks to the enduring qualities of the likes of Jim Beam, Maker's Mark, Heaven Hill and Buffalo Trace, as well as a new breed of artisanal distillers, the ranks were swelled again. By 2009, Kentucky was home to 19 distilleries. Today, that number is significantly higher, with over 90 currently producing spirit, and many more on the way, demonstrating why the future is very bright for American whisky.

Bourbon’s distinct flavour

Bardstown rickhouse

A rickhouse (for ageing whisky in barrels) at The Bardstown Bourbon Company

(Image credit: Neil Ridley)

From a style point of view bourbon gets its charismatic sweet, spicy and rich, full-bodied flavour thanks to a combination – or mash bill – of different grains: a legal requirement of no less than 51 per cent corn, often bolstered by rye – which brings a distinct herbal and peppery note, alongside wheat, providing a creamier, softer flavour and then additionally, malted barley for extra complexity. Maturing in new, charred and toasted American white oak barrels brings bourbon's rich colour and deep vanilla, cherry and sweet tobacco-led flavours, with the spirit ageing quickly, thanks to the extreme temperatures found in some of the huge 'rickhouses', where the barrels are left to slumber.

It's these two fundamental aspects – grain and oak – that distillers have really begun to tap into, to revolutionise the character of American whisky, to produce some astonishing variants using innovative techniques.

The best American whiskies on the Kentucky Bourbon Trail

Maker's Mark – the master of sustainability

Michter’s – the industry favourite

Jeptha Creed and Potter Jane – from small-scale to next-level craft

Bardstown Bourbon Co – the next frontier in innovation

Heaven Hill and Jim Beam – tradition, innovation, sustainability

Rabbit Hole – pushing the boundaries of flavour


Louisville essentials

Bardstown Bourbon

The Bardstown Bourbon Company

(Image credit: Neil Ridley)

Getting There:
Direct flights via British Airways - Heathrow to Cincinnati, or via Chicago to Louisville Airport.

Where to Stay:
The Hotel Distil Autograph Collection: 101 W Main St, Louisville, KY 40202, marriot.com

Hotel Bourré Bonne: 133 W Market St, Louisville, KY 40202, bourrebonne.com

Where to Eat and Drink:

North of Bourbon (cocktails and light dining) northofbourbon.com

610 Magnolia (modern Southern fine dining) 610magnolia.com

Cured (modern European fine dining) curedlouisville.com

The Bar at Fort Nelson (Michter's bar, serving twists on classic cocktails) michters.com

Hell Or High Water (intimate and cosy, modern cocktails, booking needed) hellorhighwaterbar.com

TOPICS

Neil Ridley is a London-based, award-winning drinks writer and presenter.  He is the co-author of eight books on spirits and cocktails including Distilled, which is now published in 14 different language editions. For the past eight years he has also served as a drinks expert on TV show Sunday Brunch on Channel 4