Pomo erectus: a perfectly aged temple to wine and architecture
Napa Valley’s Clos Pegase Winery celebrates its 30th birthday this year, just as a new biography of its architect, the late American postmodernist Michael Graves, is released. Graves was one of 20th-century architecture’s mavericks, a young modernist – one of the legendary ‘New York Five’, no less – who turned his back on the evolutionary approach of his peers to explore the less po-faced facets of architectural design. This populist approach was galvanised by product design for the likes of Alessi, Target and JCPenney, for whom Graves designed playful bestsellers that made him one of the era’s most commercially accessible designers.
Before Target and Alessi, Graves’ work was considered perverse, iconoclastic and provocative, deliberately out of step with prevailing taste. The Clos Pegase is a case in point. Riding on the tails of the then new fashion for architect-designed wineries, the project was won in a competition run by SFMOMA. Graves and his team drew up a romantic vision of a Bacchanalian temple, transporting Tuscan vistas and the mysterious landscapes of Poussin and Lorrain to the Northern Californian hills.
The brief called for a small Napa Valley fiefdom, with public tasting rooms, winemaking areas and bottle storage along with a private villa for the owner, publisher and art collector Jan Shrem. Named after one of Shrem’s favourite paintings of Pegasus by the French symbolist Odilon Redon, the complex was conceived with a sculpture park and murals by Graves and the contemporary neoclassicist Edward Schmidt. A key unrealised feature was the ‘mountain of Pegasus’, a circular amphitheatre-like structure off which walks and vistas through the vineyard were to radiate. The idea was to evoke the habitat of the legendary creature, which was said to have opened up springs simply by touching the earth with its hoof.
One of Graves’ studies for the entrance portico. Photography: Courtesy of Michael Graves Architecture & Design/Clos Pegase - Otto Baitz
‘This kind of mythological storytelling was a favourite of Michael’s at the time – he had a similar backstory for the Swan and Dolphin Hotels [at Walt Disney World in Florida],’ says Ian Volner, author of the new monograph, Michael Graves: Design for Life ($30, Princeton Architectural Press). The winery programme was eventually scaled back and the mountain lost, but Graves maintained the grand axis, using the heightened perspective created by rows of vines to focus on a classically symmetrical structure, whose geometric façades sheltered a generous courtyard – the ‘clos’ – described in 1987 by the New York Times critic Paul Goldberger as ‘a gateway to the mountains’.
‘Formally, it is composed of the very specific PoMo kit of parts Graves had first realised in his 1980 Venice Biennale installation,’ Volner explains. ‘The ellipse, like an exaggerated [semi-circular] Diocletian window; the faux rustication in the painting program; the repetition of Roman lattices, columnar volumes...’ The New York-based writer met Graves many times, and the book was initially planned as a ‘collaborative memoir’. Graves’ death in 2015, at the age of 80, turned it into a biography with input from clients, critics and collaborators.
Clos Pegase still holds a fascination. It is a building with a narrative, not just about the wine-making process, but about the power of architecture to command and transform its surroundings. Ultimately, however, the stylistic and academic nuances of the era have been blurred by distance and skewed by knowledge of Graves’ commercial acumen and sense of fun – this is the man who used the Seven Dwarfs as caryatids on Disney’s Michael D Eisner Building. The marriage of pop culture and commerce is rarely so considered. Shrem sold up in 2012, but the winery retains its playful mystery, out of time from the moment it was built.
As originally featured in the December 2017 issue of Wallpaper* (W*225)