Cambridge Central Mosque: an inclusive alternative Stirling Prize winner
Marks Barfield Architects’ Cambridge Central Mosque, argues architectural writer Shukri Sultan, is a progressive turning point in the design of British mosques – and, while it didn’t triumph in this year’s Stirling Prize, its inclusive stance makes it a worthy alternative winner
The 2021 Stirling Prize nomination of the Cambridge Central Mosque by Marks Barfield Architects raised important questions as to how one should judge a sacred space. Should the defining criteria be aesthetic, cultural or perhaps environmental? I argue for looking at how it treats its female worshippers. The Cambridge Central Mosque heralds itself as being an inclusive, female-friendly mosque; one that seeks to welcome all through its very design.
When journeying to an unfamiliar mosque, I mentally prepare myself for the possibility of having to either argue my way in or sneak into the building. That is because some mosques, due to cultural and generational differences, can sometimes operate like a social club for men. Even when allowed in, women are often physically marginalised by the very spatial arrangement of the building. Due to limited space or poor design, they can still find themselves isolated from the rest of the congregation, often banished to pray in a windowless cupboard, as the women’s prayer hall is often treated like cycling lanes – a last-minute afterthought.
The single prayer hall for both genders, seen in the original Prophet’s Mosque in Medina, a common feature in early Islamic history, is hard to come by in contemporary Britain. This could be due to practical reasons, as most British mosques occupy repurposed buildings that were formerly houses, cinemas and pubs. In addition, the religious obligation of attending the Friday prayer generally falls on men. So those who run a mosque may argue that this exclusion is justified, as women do not attend as frequently. And as most mosques are poorly funded, even in the more inclusive ones, women can still find themselves sequestered away in a separate room, due to limited space or poor design. What distinguishes the Cambridge Central Mosque is that from the onset, women’s needs were central in the design process.
In an early community consultation prior to Marks Barfield’s commission, a survey was taken to gather the opinions and preferences of the diverse group of Muslim women present in Cambridge. The result of this survey was taken on board in the design process and culminated in the creation of three adaptable prayer spaces that met the needs of this culturally diverse community.
On entering the single prayer hall, women are given a choice of whether to sit behind or in front of the series mashrabiya screens of varying heights present in the space. At the rear end of the prayer hall is another prayer space that is separated by soundproof glass. The design, led by Marks Barfield managing director Julia Barfield, caters to the needs of women with young children. Mothers can still listen and see the wider congregation while their children can run and shout without disturbing other members of the congregation. The space is also equipped with a wet play area and mini mihrab that acts as a focal point of the room.
A set of steps leading off from the mother and children room takes you to the third and final prayer space. Elevated above the main prayer hall is the Baraka Khan Gallery, which gives women a unique vantage point of the swooping internal timber structure.
The low-rise building is devoid of towering minarets and is set back from the road with a portico and communal garden at the front. The mosque is more than just a place of worship – it is a community centre open to all. It features a self-service community café and an education room that is currently hosting an exhibition on Medieval Islamic Scientific Instruments.
I was nervous during my short walk from the train station to the mosque; but this was due to anticipation and not the usual, underlying fear that I might be refused entry. Despite doubts, upon entering the prayer space, I was overcome by both the stillness and warmth of the place.
The Cambridge Central Mosque marks an important turning point in the architectural articulation of Islam in Britain. It serves as a guide for an inclusive, brighter future. §