The notion of a pre- or post-theatre supper takes on new allure when the restaurant and the entertainment share the same owner. Last month (September 2025), independent film studio and distributor A24 revived a piece of Village history with the reopening of the century-old Cherry Lane Theatre, the oldest Off-Broadway venue in New York, following a multi-year restoration. Alongside a fresh roster of theatre, comedy, music and film, the venue now also offers Wild Cherry, an arthouse-style restaurant that has swiftly become one of the city’s hot tickets.
Wild Cherry opens inside Cherry Lane Theatre
True to A24’s understated aesthetic, Wild Cherry favours intimacy over spectacle. The 45-seat room, led by chefs Lee Hanson and Riad Nasr (of Le Veau d’Or, Le Rock and Frenchette), feels equal parts neighbourhood haunt and cinematic vignette. Designed by Zeb Stewart, known for Brooklyn’s Hotel Delmano, Café Colette and Frenchette, the space layers nostalgia with subtle glamour: deep green banquettes and limewash wall paint cast a moody glow beneath a slatted ceiling, while funfair bulbs and chequerboard floors nod to retro diners. A striking 12-seat horseshoe bar anchors the room.
The menu plays its part with considered flair. Raw seafood leads the opening act (oysters, tuna crudo, Bang’s Island mussels, whole dressed crab) before giving way to heartier crowd-pleasers: a lobster club, roasted monkfish kebab and a cheeseburger with just the right swagger. A steak for two arrives with baked potato, green salad and a swirl of soft-serve, while coconut cake offers a gentle curtain call. To drink, classic cocktails and natural wines set the tone, but the true showstopper is the Scorpion Bowl, a shared concoction served in vintage Murano glass – the wild cherry on top of an already cinematic night out.
Scorpion Bowl
Wild Cherry is located at 38 Commerce St, New York, NY 10014, United States.
-
Tour Aflalo’s first retail space, a gallery-like studio in New YorkLight-filled and elegant, Aflalo has opened its first retail space in a classic Soho loft, reimagined by Nordic Knots Studio
-
This Toronto pizzeria hides a sultry bar with serious biteNorth of Brooklyn unveils a fresh, two-level outpost where crisp, light-filled minimalism gives way to a warmer, neon-lit upstairs area
-
A Lagos exhibition celebrates Fela Kuti's defining soundAn exhibition, Afrobeat Rebellion, currently showing at the Ecobank PanAfrican Centre in Lagos, explores the life of Afrobeat father Fela Anikulapo-Kuti
-
The W New York, Union Square gets a grown-up revamp by Rockwell GroupThe noughties hotspot has reopened with a more mature – yet never muted –new look. Wallpaper* checks in
-
An around-the-world art tour with RosewoodFrom London to New York, Amsterdam and São Paulo, the hotel group showcases curated art that reflects the unique local context
-
Dior’s new Beverly Hills dining salon raises the bar for couture cuisineFrom Peter Marino’s onyx bar and faceted mirrored walls to Nicole Wittenberg’s vast, immersive botanical canvas, Dior’s first restaurant outside Paris is here
-
This new Los Angeles restaurant is a mischievous blend of dive bar and 'psychedelic honky tonk'At Marvito, small-batch tequila and a classic rock soundtrack create a delightfully nostalgic night out
-
Fantasy – and incredible seafood – await at Carbone Riviera, now open at the Bellagio in Las VegasInterior design powerhouse Martin Brudnizki drew on the Côte d'Azur and Picasso’s ceramics for Major Food Group’s latest Sin City outpost
-
At Café Zaffri in New York, history is served with a rebellious streakThe team behind Raf's unveils a new Union Square haunt that dishes up redefined Levantine cuisine in a reimagined Old New York dining room
-
Welcome to Polymath Park, where you can spend the night in a Frank Lloyd Wright masterpieceA pair of determined Wright devotees have turned four endangered modernist houses into an overnight design retreat
-
Faena New York just landed in the Big Apple – and it's an excuse for a good timeArgentine hotelier Alan Faena’s first New York address serves up high-octane hospitality with a dash of leopard print
