After a challenging year for Zaha Hadid Architects that has seen the firm's design for the £1.3 billion Tokyo Olympic Stadium scaled back over concerns about spiralling costs (before being scrapped altogether by the Japanese government), the firm have hit back with a 23 minute-long film arguing the case for the controversial design to go ahead.
Spelling out the practicalities of its vision, the firm's movie promises that the design, which has been in development for two years already and cost the Japanese government ¥1.47 billion in fees, is ready to start construction on site this year and will be completed for the 2019 Rugby World Cup, as well as the test events before the summer Olympics in 2020. 'To start the design from scratch is an unnecessary risk that we think the government should reconsider if its aim is to achieve a lower price than ¥252 billion,' the firm says.
The architects suggest that introducing more competition between the contractors could help to reduce costs further, as well as allow for the implementation of a time-saving and cost-cutting parallel construction approach. '¥252 billion is the current price in Tokyo for a basic 80,000 [seater] stadium on that site,' the video states. 'It should also be understood that the immovable deadlines [for events] such as the Olympics, combined with a limited competition in the market place create inflated prices. The determining factor in the price is the market and the demand on materials and labour. The design is not the determining factor in these circumstances. The design should be seen as the only way to achieve value for money in the market.'
As well as the practicalities, the film confronts the criticism it has received for being at odds with its context by offering enticing new renders and fly-throughs while detailing its references to Japanese culture – a silhouette inspired by traditional Japanese landscape bridges, flower petal geometry, and Japanese timber louvres and pedestrian walkways are just a few that are highlighted. Design decisions and details are explained in depth, from lighting to roof dimensions and shape, and how they will impact upon the surrounding environment.
The firm hopes that the video, accompanied by an explanatory booklet, will 'help the public understanding of the project and debate on the next steps for the New National Stadium'. Whether this last ditch effort can reverse the government's decision remains to be seen.
The film highlights the scheme's practicalities, stating that the design is ready to start construction on site this year and will be ready for the 2019 Rugby World Cup, as well as the test events before the summer Olympics in 2020
The new stadium design has been in development for two years already and cost the Japanese government ¥1.47 billion in fees to ZHA
In the film, the firm states, 'To start the design from scratch is an unnecessary risk that we think the government should reconsider if its aim is to achieve a lower price than ¥252 billion'
The architects suggest that introducing a new contractor bidding process could help to reduce costs further, as well as allow for the implementation of a time-saving and cost-cutting parallel construction approach
Defending itself against the criticism of spiralling costs, ZHA explains, 'The determining factor in the price is the market and the demand on materials and labour. The design is not the determining factor in these circumstances. The design should be seen as the only way to achieve value for money in the market'
As well as highlighting the practicalities of going ahead with the proposed design, the film confronts the criticism the scheme has received for being at odds with its context
While enticing renders and fly-throughs provide new perspectives, the film also highlights the scheme's references to Japanese culture
Design decisions are explained in great detail – from lighting to roof dimensions and shape, and how they will impact upon the surrounding environment
The firm hopes that the video, accompanied by an explanatory booklet, will 'help the public understanding of the project and debate on the next steps for the New National Stadium'
INFORMATION
Imagery courtesy Methanoi
-
Kembra Pfahler revisits ‘The Manual of Action’ for CIRCAArtist Kembra Pfahler will lead a series of classes in person and online, with a short film streamed from Piccadilly Circus in London, as well as in Berlin, Milan and Seoul, over three months until 30 June 2024
-
Monospinal is a Japanese gaming company’s HQ inspired by its product’s worldA Japanese design studio fulfils its quest to take Monospinal, the Tokyo HQ of a video game developer, to the next level
-
Fenix and Federica Sala Challenge Designers to double upCurator Federica Sala and innovative interiors material brand Fenix's Design Duo Double Feature project brings three design duos together to create dual-purpose furniture
-
Monospinal is a Japanese gaming company’s HQ inspired by its product’s world
A Japanese design studio fulfils its quest to take Monospinal, the Tokyo HQ of a video game developer, to the next level
-
Modern Japanese houses inspiring minimalism and avant-garde livingWe tour the best Japanese architecture and modern Japanese houses designed by international and local architects that open up possibilities for all types of lifestyle, from minimalist to communal in Japanese architecture.
-
An Aoyama House exemplifies a synergetic architect and client relationshipA client’s faith in his architect pays dividends in Aoyama House; a light-filled, effortlessly elegant Tokyo home
-
Tokyo home Le49Ⅱ brings together drama, domestic luxury and hybrid working habits
Le49Ⅱ by Japanese architects Apollo is a Tokyo home for a young family with hybrid working habits
-
Takeshi Ikeuchi’s kei truck is a minimalist Japanese mobile showroomTakeshi Ikeuchi's kei truck design is a Japanese timber specialist’s minimalist mobile showroom
-
Nekoyacho Bldg is a Hiroshima office on a crossroads of 'food, work and entertainment'Nekoyacho Bldg has been designed by Suppose Design Office as a 21st century workspace in Hiroshima, Japan
-
Heatherwick Studio’s Azabudai Hills district launches as Tokyo’s newest city-in-a-cityTokyo welcomes the Azabudai Hills district, designed by Heatherwick Studio and constructed as a city-in-a-city after over three decades of planning
-
Toranomon Hills Station by OMA adds dynamism to the Tokyo skylineToranomon Hills Station is OMA's first tower in Tokyo - as well as a project expanding and evolving the high rise typology
